Home/Blog/Automation

The lift that sat broken for three days

A lift broken since Friday. An eighty-seven-year-old resident who hadn't come down in three days. And the warning, waiting its turn in the inbox beneath a complaint about a bike in the hallway.

Marisa's phone rang on a Monday at ten past nine, before she'd even had time to put her bag down. It was the chairman of a residents' association on Calle Uría, and he wasn't calling to say good morning.

—Marisa, the lift's been out since Friday. Doña Amparo, on the fifth floor, hasn't come down in three days. She's eighty-seven. Did you know about this?

Marisa didn't know. She hung up, opened her email and searched. There it was: a message from Friday at ten past six in the evening, from the caretaker, subject line "lift". It had come in on a Friday right at closing time, among sixty other emails, and nobody had opened it until that Monday morning, while the chairman was telling her over the phone.

Marisa runs a property management firm in Gijón. She and two others look after forty-odd residents' associations: fees, special levies, meetings, insurance, the plumber, the lift company, the neighbour complaining about the one who parks in his space. All of it comes in through one place: an email inbox, admin@, checked by whoever can, whenever they can.

An inbox where everything weighed the same

Forty, fifty, sixty emails landed in that inbox every day. And they all came in the same way, in a queue, by order of arrival. The one warning about a water leak in a garage and the one asking for a duplicate receipt. The one about the broken lift and the one from the neighbour protesting because someone had left a bike in the hallway. One after another, the same size, the same colour.

Marisa and her team opened them from the top, as they came in, and answered what there was time for. It's not that they didn't work; they worked all day. It's that there was no way to know, at a glance, which of those sixty emails was the one that couldn't wait. They all looked alike until you opened them. And the one that was on fire could be sitting at number forty-one, beneath forty that weren't.

The lift one had come in on a Friday at just gone six. By that hour the office was already shutting up. On Monday, when someone finally got to it, doña Amparo had spent three days unable to get down to the street.

What she asked for and what she needed

Marisa called me asking, more or less, for more hands. Another person to empty the inbox, or longer hours, or someone to check the email at weekends on a rota. She was convinced the problem was one of volume: a lot of emails came in and they couldn't keep up.

But the problem wasn't how many emails came in. It was that they came in with no order of importance. Even if she hired someone else, that person would still open them from the top, one by one, with no way of knowing which was urgent until they read it. What Marisa needed wasn't to read faster. It was for something, as each email came in, to say before it was even opened: this is an emergency, this can wait, and this one belongs to the Calle Uría association.

How it works, no smoke

What we built reads each email as it comes in, before anyone else, and puts three labels on it. One for what it is: a breakdown, a complaint, an administrative task, a receipt. One for how urgent it looks: a broken lift or a water leak isn't the same as a question about a fee. And one for which association it belongs to, so nobody has to work that out each time.

With that, the inbox stops being a queue by order of arrival and becomes ordered by what's on fire. Emergencies rise to the very top, flagged. What can wait waits, but in its place. When Marisa opens her email in the morning, the first thing she sees isn't the most recent email: it's the most urgent one.

We have to be honest about what this is and what it isn't. It doesn't read minds: a perfectly polite email can hide an emergency, and now and then it will flag as routine something that wasn't, or the other way round. That's why it doesn't decide on its own; it sorts and warns, and there's still a person on top who confirms. And it doesn't fix the lift: the technician does that. All it does is make sure the email about the lift doesn't sit three days unopened beneath a complaint about a bike in the hallway.

What changed

The difference showed on the first day. An email about a boiler that had run out of hot water in the middle of November came in mid-afternoon and rose on its own to the top of the inbox, in red. They saw it within minutes, not the next day. Marisa sent the technician that same afternoon.

Emergencies stopped hiding. Not because fewer came in —the same number come in— but because they no longer mix with what isn't urgent. What can wait still waits, but nobody loses the morning deciding what to look at first: it comes decided. And each association's matters arrive with the name already on them, without having to open them to know whose they are.

The three-day lift hasn't happened again. Marisa put it her own way:

—Now what's on fire is right at the top. Before, it was on fire in the middle of the pile.

The pile where everything weighs the same

What was happening to Marisa happens to anyone who receives a lot through one single place: an inbox, a business WhatsApp, a form. Everything comes in the same way, by order of arrival, and the urgent hides among what isn't without anyone doing it on purpose. It isn't a failing of the people; it's a failing of the pile.

We didn't have to change email systems or build anything complicated. We had to teach the inbox to tell what's on fire from what can wait, and to put each thing where it belongs before a human looks at it. So that a broken lift doesn't have to wait its turn behind a bike in the hallway.

Because a management firm can do everything right —answer, handle, never lose an email— and still arrive late to the one thing that truly couldn't wait. All it takes is for the urgent to come in the same queue as what isn't, with no one separating them.

When everything comes in through the same place, the urgent hides

A shared inbox sorts by order of arrival, not by importance. With fifty or sixty emails a day, what can't wait ends up buried among what can, and no one does it on purpose: it's the queue itself that hides it. Hiring more hands doesn't fix it, because the problem isn't volume, it's the lack of order.

Classifying each message as it comes in —what it is, how urgent, whose it is— turns the pile into a list ordered by what's on fire. There's still a person deciding; what changes is that the important thing is seen first, not on the third day.

Does the urgent hide among what can wait?

If you receive a lot through one inbox, a WhatsApp or a form, and emergencies get mixed in with routine, each message can be classified as it comes in and what's on fire put right at the top, with a person who confirms. We can look at it together.

Let's talk